I was really disturbed to see this
site, especially after reading
this. They could not conflict more. It is a sad day when Christians spend thousands upon thousands of dollars to tour orphanages and chalk it up to “visiting orphans” as commanded in the Bible, despite the harm that it can cause.
Is there no concern about the children’s safety? Even if a background check is run on someone, that doesn’t always catch pedophilia! And what an opportunity for a pedophile. Emotionally needy children + little supervision + unknown visitor from a foreign country with money = __________. You fill in the blank. Anyone who has spent ANY amount of time in a Ugandan orphanage knows the liberties that can be taken and lack of good supervision of volunteers.
Although I despise the word “orphan”, lets just say that I have a huge concern for them, as I’ve had some very personal experiences regarding “them”. I volunteered for two years at my daughters babies home before adopting her and knew many, many, kids during that time. I am still haunted and pray for those kids as the majority went on into big money making orphanages.It hurts to think of Ella’s little buddies, Trevor, James, Maddox, etc who are also six years old now, sitting in institutions. It makes me sick to think of my vulnerable, pretty little daughter in one.
Suffice to say, Ella and the other children at her babies home between the years of 2006-2008 changed my life. These people are as real to me as Ella is. Which is why I hate to see Paul’s command to “visit” and care for orphans misused in the context of taking tour trips to foreign countries “to visit” the poor children there.
The best thing for an “orphan” is to be placed back with their family, considering that the family is safe. It’s okay to be poor. Help the poor family alleviate their poverty rather than simply remove their child and providing for it somewhere else. One of the key points in Corbett and Fikkert’s book,
When Helping Hurts, is never to do something for someone that they could do for themselves. Like, um, er, raise their child.
If it’s not possible to place the child back with his or her family or no one has any idea where the family is, as in the case of truly abandoned children, then the next best step would be to find the kid an adoptive family. Preferably a local one. If a local adoptive family can’t be found, then try an international one. If that’s not possible, than find the child a local foster family. I don’t really see why an institution should ever be needed, unless the child needs specialized medical care that a foster family couldn’t provide and the institution can provide it. This is not impossible, as
this article shows.
Oh. But wait. Without these institutions, how could their be a “visiting orphans” organization? How will many local Pastors make money? My point? GET CHILDREN OUT OF INSTITUTIONS – DON’T PAT YOURSELF ON THE BACK FOR SPENDING THOUSANDS OF DOLLARS TO GO VIST THEM! IT DOES MORE HARM THAN GOOD. This is not what the Scriptures mean when they tell us to care for and visit the orphans and widows! If I was using skype I’d use the “facepalm” smiley right now.
It really saddens me when Christians think that this is the best that they can do. What about the social orphans in the U.S? Rather than spending a ton of money for a two to four week trip overseas to visit their poor children, why don’t you become a foster parent? There’s a crap load of children in the United States who are far worse off than say, a Ugandan “orphan”. With the take over of drugs in our country you see reports everyday about children who have been reported “missing”, only to be found killed by their drug addicted parents. Why don’t you go visit them? More than likely they’ll even understand English and know what you’re saying!
So, my advice is to take the three to four thousand that you’d spend on a cool trip overseas to “visit” poor foreign children and a) send it to an organization like VIVA or b)reach out to a foster child or poor child in the U.S (or your respective country). Heck, maybe even foster one!
Come on Christians! We can do better than this. This is embarrassing.